Real-life drama, real-life lessons

JMC students talk about their reactions to covering capital murder trial


With the real-life drama of James Trimble's triple-homicide trial as a classroom, Kent JMC students received a valuable learning opportunity by covering the trial alongside professional journalists. With one of the victims being a Kent State University student, they also got an up close and personal lesson on balancing emotion and objectivity when the story hits close to home. JMC graduate student Jerome Anderson asked three students who covered the trial about their reactions. Students were Broadcast Journalism majors Shannon Peluso and Jean-Marie Papoi and Newspaper major Mike Lewis.

Talk about how you felt walking into the courtroom for the first time. Have your feelings about the experience changed since then?

Peluso: "Walking into the court room was almost an exhilarating experience. As a beginning journalist, I always think about the events I'll have to cover and things that I will see. I was excited to get this opportunity. It's not every day that you get to sit in on a capital murder trial. Every time I get the opportunity to cover it, I do. I look forward to going into the courtroom and experiencing the trial first hand."

Lewis: "I had been in a courtroom before for minor traffic violations, so I wasn't too surprised. It was the first, however, I had gone with a press pass. The setting and situation became very real when Trimble was brought in. When the jury came in and everybody had to stand, I realized the amount of respect paid to those twelve individuals. Never before had I fully appreciated the justice system and the burden placed on the jurors...."


Shannon Peluso

Papoi:  "I was extremely nervous on my first day in the courtroom, mainly because of being in the same room with (James) Trimble. We had a decent amount of preparation in class before and I already know a good deal about the trial just from following it through TV2 and the local papers. But to be there in person experiencing it first hand made me look at things differently. I suppose it's mainly because I've seen and heard things most people don't get to see and it totally changed my perspective."

Have you had the opportunity to interact with professional journalists covering the trial? What was that experience like?

Peluso:  "Yes, as a matter of fact I sat next to a reporter from the Akron Beacon Journal.   He explained a few things to me that I didn't understand and that was extremely helpful.   We even shared notes and talked about a few of the conditions of the trial during a break. The other professional journalists are extremely helpful as well. It's refreshing to know that the people I will be working with for the next 30 years of my life are willing to help the fresh blood."

Lewis: "Yes, I did have an opportunity to interact with other journalists. Specifically, I spoke with Ed Meyer of the Akron Beacon Journal and Dave O'Brien of the Record Courier.
Both were nice. Meyer complimented the Daily Kent Stater. He also answered some of my questions about the trial like whether he thought the state had proven murder in all three cases? He said no, only in the case of the little boy. It also helped to be able to ask somebody if I missed a name or how it was spelled. At the same time, I observed him. He typed his story on his laptop while court was in session. I think we both took very similar notes, but it appeared he was correlating previous notes with new bits of testimony then joting ideas down. In both cases, I read the finished work the next day. All three of us told the story differently, but Meyers' was closer to my version than O'Brien. I thought he went into too much detail."

Papoi:  "This was my favorite part! My second time there I talked with two FOX 8 camera guys, and at the end of the day they shared their pool tape with me to give me great footage that I didn't get because my tape ran out. We talked about careers, some of the experiences they've had in the field, and what to expect starting out at a station. I also talked with a tech guy and a reporter form 19 Action News who were very helpful when it came to setting up my equipment. That day I felt like a real reporter and forgot about school for a moment. All I could focus on was the trial and how I would present my information for the news that evening."

Lewis: "Yes, I think it will give me an advantage. How many other student journalists covered a capital murder trial in the U.S.? I kept every clip from the ABJ, DKS and the RC. From reading those clips, I learned the best way to write a story dealing with the courts. Detail and accuracy are most important. Without a doubt,


Mike Lewis

One of the victims, Sarah Positano, was a Kent State student. Though the testimony, you heard, were you able to maintain your objectivity? Are some days more emotional for you than others?

Peluso: "It's difficult, but this is what we've been trained to do, and what we've been asking for. This is a true test of students' abilities to work as journalists. I'm not going to lie and say it wasn't hard to see the photographs and hear (Sarah's) voice on the 911 tapes.   But, when I enter the courtroom I try to clear my head and refresh my memory with the facts of the case; that way I won't feel obliged to enter opinion."

Lewis: "Yes, I think I did maintain objectivity. Sarah was one of my peers. Though I did not know her, her death struck a chord around campus and I remember that. Often, I found myself thinking about her and how scared she must have been. She was loved and from the sound of it was a very giving person. My objectivity had to be maintained between myself and the students at KSU and between myself and the public. I wrote about the autopsy photos, but I didn't go into too much detail. People were already familiar with the case and how she died. I didn't want them to relive that, but I did have to tell other people how she died. Clearly, I choose my words carefully so as to leave Sarah all the dignity she deserved. That was most important. On the other note, the Record Courier went into graphic detail about the photos. They separated themselves and told the story the way they thought it should be told. I asked myself if telling readers the path of the bullet through Sarah's body was important. Would they learn from it? Could they understand it? I thought it would be too much, especially for all of Sarah's friends."

Papoi: "You know, this is just a disturbing case, but I think it really hits home for students because one of the victims was just like us.  All of the testimony was emotional, especially because of the mother and child that were killed, but I can say I'm very glad I didn't attend the day the focused on Positano. I read the article next day about the 911 tapes and heard her voice on the news...it just makes you thing about this life that was ended for no reason.   I can't even imagine the fear she went through. I almost feel as if I knew her. I feel I have remained objective, thought.   It's interesting trying to fill in bits and pieces of the trial. There are a lot of factors to take into consideration before making a decision."

Do you think having this experience will give you an advantage over other journalism students?

Peluso: "We are already blessed with having an incredible journalism program at Kent State. But no one can deny that the best experience is "real world" experience. It doesn't get much better or more real than this."

Jean-Marie Papoi

the "real world" experience helped me understand my job, my audience and what I was there to do."

Papoi:  "I feel fortunate that our class got this opportunity. If you think about it, we got to live one or two days as actual reporters, spending time in the courtroom listening to the presentations and taking video, then rushing back to the newsroom to put together a story for that night. It was all very exciting, and if my first assignment at my first job is to cover a court case, I'll have no problems whatsoever."

Students cover capital murder trial

Return to JMC Home Page

Copyright © School of Journalism and Mass Communication 130 Taylor Hall Kent State University Kent OH 44242
330-672-2572
http://www.kent.edu